RU

The procedure for the reviewing the manuscripts for publication in the Proceedings of the VNIIG

  1. All manuscripts submitted for publication in the Proceedings of the VNIIG shall be reviewed. The Editorial Council of B.E. Vedeneev VNIIG recommends to submit papers for peer review to two reviewers.
  2. The Executive Secretary checks the paper for compliance with the rules of registration and the profile of the Proceedings.
  3. The dates of paper review may vary depending on a specific situation but should not exceed ten working days.
  4. The review addresses the following questions:
    1. how the content of the paper corresponds to the topic stated in the title;
    2. how the paper meets modern scientific achievements;
    3. the availability of the paper for the reader from the point of view of presentation, language, form, clarity of figures, tables, charts, formulas;
    4. the value of the paper with regard to previously published literature;
    5. evaluation of the paper for borrowings and plagiarism;
    6. specific positive and negative aspects of the work as well as suggestions for revision and supplement of the paper;
    7. The verdict about the possibility to publish the paper with the introduction of the mentioned modifications, the impossibility to publish the paper in Proceedings of the VNIIG.
  5. If the review contains the recommendations on correction and modification of the paper, the Executive Secretary sends the review text to the author with the suggestion to take them into account during the preparing of a new option or to refute them argumentatively (partially or fully).
  6. The paper not recommended for publication by the reviewer will not be accepted for reconsideration. The texts of the negative reviews with justification of refusal are sent to the author by e-mail, fax or regular mail.
  7. The Editorial Council considers papers on an individual basis, if necessary, gives them for additional review by the members of Editorial Council or other specialists.
  8. In the case of a positive decision of the admission of the paper for publication the Executive Secretary informs the author of this and notes the date of publication. The review is sent to the author by e-mail, fax or regular mail.
  9. The decision to publish the paper, structure of the Proceedings shall be taken by simple majority of votes of the Editorial Council members.
  10. The review originals are kept in the editorial office of the Proceedings of the VNIIG for five years.
  11. Copies of the reviews are sent to the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation if the editorial board of publication gets the relevant request.